Great, fits well
It fits, it looks good, it feels good, my wife loves it, it must be good.
I'm overjoyed to finally find a t-shirt that fits! Wearing this shirt is like living in a dream, one I never thought would be realized for my tall self. But really, the material is quite soft, but not flimsy. It fits well around and is long enough. I have yet to see how well it lasts, but I'm pleased otherwise. It did shrink a little in the laundry, but not too much. A little shrinking is pretty normal. I find myself moving other clothes out of the way and only wanting to wear my clothes from American Tall. And no, I am not being reimbursed for saying this and I am not affiliated in any way.
Best fitting shirt I've ever had
I was so happy when I got this shirt. I'd only bought one to try it out but immediately bought 5 more in various colors. The torso is nice and long while remaining tapered.